Home > Blog > The Dark Side of Leadership > Your Leadership Yoda

Your Leadership Yoda

by Dave Logan on December 27, 2011

There is a battle raging in your life, right now, between two parts of yourself: Leadership Yoda and Leadership Saboteur. Leadership Yoda wants you to gain insights and grow in wisdom and power. Leadership Yoda seeks inner growth that will fuel your work as a leader in 2012 and beyond. Leadership Saboteur wants none of this to happen.

Leadership Yoda loves this time of year the most. Our biology, far older than electric lights, wants to spend the extra hours of darkness huddling close with our tribe and share stories rich with meaning and values. During this time of year when the briskness of life turns into a stroll, Leadership Yoda wants to learn the unlearned, think the unthought, and clarify the unclarified.

Leadership Yoda is especially fond of spending time with wise friends and mentors. At the top of my gratitude list this holiday season was a breakfast meeting with Warren Bennis. Dr. Bennis’ liberal arts education, wisdom-seeking compassion, and tough love expressed as questions, came together with his first query, borrowed from Emerson: “What has become clear to you since we last met?”

Hours passed and we were stunned to see that breakfast time had become lunch. After four hours with Dr. Bennis, my inner Leadership Yoda was pleased well, he was.

And throughout the meeting, I felt the stirrings of Leadership Saboteur. His work is to prevent what Steve Zaffron and I called “becoming Shogun of your own life” in Three Laws of Performance. This person, alive in every one of us, wants us to never reflect, never examine our concepts and assumptions, and never learn from experience. He seeks to maintain the status quo of your life, and by extension, of the world.

Dr. Bennis wrote about what drives the Leadership Saboteur in his 1976 article “Learning Some Basic Truisms About Leadership” (part of Why Leaders Can’t Lead) and reprinted in The Essential Bennis): “I had become the victim of a vast, amorphous, unwitting, unconscious conspiracy to prevent me from doing anything whatever to change the university [of Cincinnati]’s status quo.” He goes on to find the underpinnings of the conspiracy, and explains: “Routine work drives out non-routine work and smothers to death all creative planning, all fundamental change in the university—or any institution.”

Leadership Saboteur seeks to displace reflection-causing epiphanies, and work that would create transformation, structural and lasting change, with routine work, and distractions. If the Leadership Saboteur were a god, he would raise his arms and call forth the modern tempests of traffic and ticked-off shoppers. He would implement social norms about gift giving—if I give you a present, you have to give one back. He would convert our gadgets into reflection-interrupting demands. He would own stock in Microsoft and Apple, and distract us further by making them not work together at a time with then IT people are on vacation.

He would fill our schedules with holiday parties, making sure they were well stocked with alcohol to prevent heart-level connection with our colleagues and reflection beyond drunken toasts of love and appreciation that are awkward to those who drink more water than Grey Goose.

One of Leadership Saboteur’s strongest assets is our revolution of confusion. He screams “BS!” when people quote Salvador Dali: “What is important is to spread confusion, not eliminate it.” The Leadership Saboteur and Leadership Yoda both know that confusion is like the turbulence early test flight pilots reported as they neared the speed of sound. After pushing through, Chuck Yeager and his fellow speed pioneers regained full control of their planes, and felt a surge of acceleration.

Confusion comes with a sense of discomfort, and so Leadership Saboteur often whispers: “this is a waste of time” and then transfers our attention to any distraction, like an iPhone buzz announcing the arrival of another one-day only special Macy’s.

For Leadership Yoda to have a few days to do his work, Leadership Saboteur has to be put in a penalty box. There are times when the opposite needs to happen—to get work done and check off items on our to-do list—but the end of the year is not one of them.

How, then, do we give Leadership Yoda fighting chance?

First, make use of the time now. After the end of Christmas or Hanukkah, and before the world starts work again in January, there’s a period of time that drives the Saboteur nuts. The days are still short, and the psychobiological drive to reflect is still strong, and the errands can wait. We can return gifts later. The tree will be fine another few days. If we go to work, let’s face it, not much happens. TiVo hasn’t recorded anything good since the finale of American Horror Story, and thanks to Hollywood’s lack of creativity, we can watch all the “must see” movies in one day—with several hours to spare.

Second, take a nod from David Allen and get a big box, write on it “Not Doing Now” and dump everything in it. Really. Presents to be returned. Our laptop. Our iPhone. Our TiVo remote. Our to-do list. Just for a little while. If there’s something you just have to do, write it on a piece of paper and toss it in the box.

Third, get Leadership Yoda started with a conversation with someone wise. I was fortunate to have breakfast with Warren Bennis. You can, too, by picking up The Essential Bennis. Or another book, but that book must be written in code.

The people who write good leadership books have a problem. If we write about the mindset of a leader, or the epiphanies required to lead effectively, the Leadership Saboteur in the reader’s mind screams that this is confusing and a waste of time. If, on the other hand, we write something practical, it may get a lot of readers, but doesn’t do much to create leaders. I sounded off on such books in a recent Money Watch blog.

The writer has to use bait-and-switch by talking about tips, tools, and techniques, but conveying the real message more subtly. Here’s a challenge for your Leadership Yoda: find the secret message in Tribal Leadership, or in Bennis’ Organizing Genius, or in the epilogue of Eric Reis’ The Lean Startup.

To satisfy Leadership Yoda, the book has to be about leadership, not about life effectiveness (e.g., Stephen Covey’s Seven Habits of Highly Effective People), spirituality (e.g., M. Scott Peck’s Road Less Traveled), or personal discovery (e.g., Tom Rath’s StrengthsFinder 2.0). Also, this is not the time to crack open that leather-bound set of great books your uncle got you as a graduation present. All of these are good books, but they’re not about leadership.

Fourth, don’t merely read, converse. Imagine the words on the page were uttered by someone sitting across from you. Listen deeply and Leadership Yoda will respond. Write down what he says, in a notebook, or if you’re like me, in the margins of the book you’re reading.

Fifth, keep going until Leadership Yoda starts speaking without the need for prompting. This isn’t mystical, and if you hear the voices of spirits, stop reading and dial 911.

You’ll just start thinking of your life and how it relates to the principles you’re reading. When Leadership Yoda starts talking, just listen. Leadership Yoda does convey wisdom, but mostly, he asks great questions, and the leadership insights come in dwelling in those questions. When you’re confused or this effort seems pointless, celebrate. Leadership Yoda will smile when you do, he will.

Sixth, once Leadership Yoda is engaged, stay in a reflective mindset. Carry something to write down your thoughts, insights, or questions. This is a perfect time to do something physical—go to the gym, take a walk or a long run. Keep a notepad by the bed, so that when you have ideas in the fog of early wakefulness, you write them down before they burn off.

Seventh, before January 1, spend a few hours in this reflective mindset reviewing the year. If you keep a journal, read it. If you don’t, reread old emails, or scroll through your calendar. What happened? What were the patterns? What did you learn? What did you fail to learn that would have made you more effective? What did you learn about leadership? What will you do differently in 2012?

Finally, as the pace of life picks up in January, inform your Leadership Yoda that you will ask the following question in the future: “What has become clear to you since we last met?” Pick a date on your calendar now when you will schedule a meeting, free of distractions, with your Leadership Yoda. You might even write that question in the calendar entry, unless you have other people who will read it and refer you to HR for counseling.

The brilliance of taking some time every year for an extended meeting with Leadership Yoda is that he’ll work in the background all the time, connecting the dots, shining a light on something that has is in your dark side. He’s the ultimate brain app.

One last piece of advice. The moment these “steps” become a process, stop them immediately. Remember, routine work is domain of the Leadership Saboteur. These are ways to get a conversation with Leadership Yoda going, nothing more.

I have used this process, which is really an un-process, for over two decades. Next to family and staying healthy, I can’t recommend anything higher.

My hope is that this community will turn the last days in December into an annual Leadership Yoda convention, so that we can all learn from each other’s discoveries. To get this effort started, I hope you’ll share your thoughts from your Leadership Yoda below.

{ 26 comments… read them below or add one }

Mohit Sawhney December 28, 2011 at 9:12 am

Good thoughts Dave. I am starting a conversation with my Leadership Yoda and reflecting more. Thanks for putting this together!

Reply

Sean Benfield December 28, 2011 at 9:19 am

Dave,

Thank you once again for your insight. Reflection has turned into a valuable tool for me as well and a few of your thoughts hit home for me in particular. I had a chuckle with the concept of “don’t merely read – converse”. This resonated in particular because I’ve read Tribal Leadership several times over the last few years but there are several concepts (such as finding the noble cause) that didn’t quite hit as hard until I had a few meetings in LA and listened to the downloaded e-book as I sat in traffic during my drives from San Diego. I found myself contemplating different dimensions of the content and at times conversing as if we were sitting in class. (No need to call the psych ward – it was all in good spirit.)

The second point of your thoughts that really hit home is the concept that when your thought process becomes a formal process, it starts to become counter-productive. I’m working on building development programs for our finance organization and I consistently receive looks of confusion because the exercises that I’m advocating are not drawn up in a formal process. My answer has always been that the value of the exercise is in the thought – not in creating a would-be recipe from a checklist. It’s nice to hear affirmation that others understand that as well. You know very well that spreading conceptual thought exercises across a group of linear thinkers is a tough task, but I’m finding more ways to measure tangible results every day that the project grows.

Once again – thank you for pointing out the conflict between the inner Yoda and the inner saboteur. I’m looking forward to meeting up in 2012 and sharing the things that my inner Yoda has helped me learn since the last time. Best success in 2012.

Sean

Reply

Errol Lawson December 28, 2011 at 9:22 am

Excellent. This is just the space I am in right now. All this week my calls have been diverted to voicemail as though I am on holiday. I have been taking the time to reflect and in a sense catch up with myself. I’m really encouraged by your post, I don’t personally know Warren Bennis bit there ate some wise people in my world that I’m looking forward to catching up with in the next couple of days. Thanks again. God bless. Errol

Reply

Leonard Crofoot December 28, 2011 at 9:37 am

Dear Dave,
Wishing you and everyone at Tribal Leadership/CultureSync a beautiful season and a glorious New Year. I thank you for your leadership and the many articles you’ve written and researched. I read the Tribal Leadership book and couldn’t put it down. I underlined an enormous amount of passages. I just think it’s great book! I found strength in it at an important time in my life, which was handling affairs of our family.
You were brought to my attention thanks to a friend and coauthor of Tribal Leadership, John King.
Thank You and best Regards to you all.
Sincerely,
Leonard Crofoot

Reply

Carlton Moore December 28, 2011 at 10:34 am

Dave, your words continue to resonate with me and always bring my psyche back into tune at times when someone else’s Leadership Saboteur attempts to recruit mine for their own evil intentions. Just this morning my Leadership Yoda used the power of “The Force” to subdue a Leadership Saboteur. After reading this article, I can feel the Force shining even brighter within me.

Thanks for what you do Dave!

Reply

Fereshteh December 28, 2011 at 11:12 am

Real, heart felt, profound, and practical leadership article that compares and contrasts both the dark-side and bright-side of leadership. I will recommend that article to my clients, and workshop participants. Thank you Dave.

Reply

Ebby Benelyhau December 28, 2011 at 11:16 am

Hey Dave:
Your blog really hits home for me. I have been a big fan for the past two years or so. What I enjoy about you is that you make complicated matters very simple to understand and as result open new horizon of future that was not there before. You did it again with this blog, thanks.

Reply

Kim Tafiti December 28, 2011 at 12:10 pm

Thank you, Dave, for sharing so freely.

Reply

John Kennelly December 28, 2011 at 12:14 pm

Thanks for the inspiration! I downloaded Organizing Genius to feed the Leadership Yoda while I relax on the beach in Cancun. I hope I find it as inspirational as Tribal Leadership (my year-end read last year in Cabo).

Reply

Tyler Jorgenson (@TylerJorgenson) December 28, 2011 at 1:06 pm

Great article Dave. I love this time of year where the world seems to, for once, allow us to listen to Leadership Yoda and be introspective.

No BS cards from me on this one.

Reply

Gary December 28, 2011 at 1:22 pm

Uh … what if I live in the southern hemisphere should I be using the dark nights in June to do my thinking, huddling and conversing with my Leadership Yoda?

Gary

P.S. I live in the north … just sayin’.

Reply

Anthony January 9, 2012 at 2:12 pm

well actually I live in South Australia and I am looking to convert the post into Southern hemisphere speak so mid winter looks like the time around June to do this process. Must remember to collect the nuts and berries before I hunker down to do the work.

Great Post :-)

Reply

Emily December 28, 2011 at 3:31 pm

Great post, great reminders…

Reply

Brian Ewert December 28, 2011 at 4:11 pm

Upon arriving home this evening the house was dark and quiet, I re-kindled the fire and found myself drawn to absorb the warmth and light, your blog is one theory that fits the data.

Brian

Reply

Mickie Tagle December 28, 2011 at 6:44 pm

Beautiful! Thank you. I’m sharing with others. Happy 2011 completion and 2012 creation! : )

Reply

George Swan December 28, 2011 at 6:57 pm

Thanks, Dave, for an inspiring post. If anything, Tribal Leadership invites us all to live more present to Leadership Yoda on a daily basis, especially when we slip into the routine and mundane. I just read Christensen’s great book, “The Innovator’s Prescription”, where he describes the three domains of medicine: intuitive, empirical and precise. It reminds me of the levels of complexity, complicated and simple. Routine chores can flip into precise actions when we become present to our internal Force, our Leadership Yoda. Challenges can shift from frustration to proto-typing and experimentation (empircal mode), and confusion can shift into inquiry and conversation. Let’s call it ‘Healthy Engagement’. For the New Year, may we all stay engaged with Leadership Yoda. :-)

Reply

ernie Devita December 28, 2011 at 7:23 pm

Dave thank you for this tool.

I really like this conversation and the conversation with my leadership yoda will now undoubtedly be profound. What a
great way to get present to who I am in the world and put the 2011 in the past. And start 2012 newly. I love it!!

Thank you

Reply

Rob Peters December 29, 2011 at 4:34 am

Dave: Thank you for the post which inspired me to buy and begin reading your book “The Laws of Performance”. The Standard of Trust tribe has been working hard for the past 5 years to implement an open standard for the capture, measurement, and utilization of Relationship Capita (RC). RC is measures kept-commitments and perceptions of a leader, product, or workgroup. Your expertise on tribal leadership and breakthrough performance continues inspire me as well as validate our work. Happy New Year!

Reply

Rob Peters December 29, 2011 at 4:36 am

Dave: Thank you for the post which inspired me to buy and begin reading your book “The Three Laws of Performance”. The Standard of Trust tribe has been working hard for the past 5 years to implement an open standard for the capture, measurement, and utilization of Relationship Capital (RC). RC is measures kept-commitments and perceptions of a leader, product, or workgroup. Your expertise on tribal leadership and breakthrough performance continues to inspire me as well as validate our work. Happy New Year!

Reply

Susannah December 29, 2011 at 7:05 am

Dave, my Leadership Yoda wants to chat with your Leadership Yoda…

Reply

Dave Logan December 29, 2011 at 7:07 am

Great comments, everyone! George, can always count on you for tying together the heart and the head. Gary, laughing. I had originally typed a sentence about waiting six months if you’re in the Southern Hemisphere, but it felt like it was turning into a tax form with lots of “if-then.” Leadership Yoda was happy not, he was. Made me change it now, he did.

Reply

Salley Trefethen December 29, 2011 at 7:56 am

Thank you. Leadership saboteur was running free. So appreciate this. I have, for the moment, put her back in her playpen.

Reply

Ingrid Bredenberg December 29, 2011 at 8:56 am

I love this “time out of time” between the holidays and the new year. I use the time to reflect on the year past, write friends…or even call them! I also will do a Vision Map of the coming year. It’s an opportunity to shift from my (often dominant) cognitive, analytical thinking into my playful, creative and possibility-oriented child. Your blog was a lovely reminder. Ironically I’d checked out one of the Star Wars movies to watch this week. I’m definitely going to watch and be reinspired by Yoda…maybe even learn to talk like him.

All the best to you and the CultureSync tribe.

Reply

Sjoerd December 30, 2011 at 8:52 am

Dave,

Thank you for the stimulation and the encouragement to grab the past year and turn it into a foundation to stand on for tomorrow. After having spent the last week in making new connection and practicing sharing who I am and what I am about with my new extended family, I’m ready to spend the trip back and the run to jan 2nd in looking back and reflecting. I do already feel saboteur knocking at the door to make intention lists and I will resist.

Sjoerd

Reply

David Brown December 30, 2011 at 8:57 am

Thanks Dave for your reminder & clear articulation of the subtle battle that rages in all of us. I feel blessed to be a coach, since as one of my mentors, Julio Olalla, taught me, masterful coaching coaching is when both the client and the coach are changed after the conversation. He also admonished me to not be so smart! That continues to be my litmus test and I embrace the inquiries and welcome the confusion that comes with curiosity. It keeps me honest.
I also appreciate that you don’t throw out the baby with the bathwater, since there are also times to take action on those reflections. Every light casts a shadow, and you can’t have shadow without light.
Time to get back to emptying out my office so it can be painted, thanks to a roof leak. It’s been a lovely process triggering much reflection, some nice, some not so much. I discover some old papers and exclaim “I’ve been planning on doing that for how many years?” but then like the roof leak, I look for the path it reveals. Thanks for your reflections & best to the Tribal Leadership community.

Reply

Cindy January 1, 2012 at 10:50 am

This is right in line with my current inspiration and process. My hope for 2012 is to customize my life to suit me (aka taking risks to be genuine in all aspects of how I live and work, believing in myself, fostering work culture or finding work culture that is a good match, etc), so I’m pretty sure Leadership Yoda needs to be involved. I’m also working on that Stage 3-4 revelation; I keep listening and re-listening to Tribal Leadership on audiobook. Thank you for your thoughts and courage in putting them out into the world. I appreciate so much, your humor, genuineness, and thoughtful way of explaining. Your words are thought-provoking and I love that! Maybe some day I’ll get to meet you and have an interesting conversation. Oh yes, and btw, G5leadership? Awesome. Love it. I’m up for a year of learning!

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: